| Year | Man | Women |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Tyreek Saint (LW) Overall Grand Champion Kam Dawson ( HW) Overall Grand Champion | Katarina Herman Overall Grand Champion Katarina Herman Open Weight Grand Champion |
| 2023 | Bailey Murphy (LW) Overall Grand Champion Bailey Murphy (VFT) Overall Grand Champion | Ki’tana Everett Overall Grand Champion |
| 2022 | Bailey Murphy Open Weight Grand Champion Kristian Rivas HW Grand Champion Bailey Murphy LW Grand Champion | Anne-Sara Cayer Open Weight Grand Champion Anne-Sara Cayer Overall Weight Grand Champion |
| 2019 | Tyreek Saint Open Weight Anthony Merricks HW Grand Champion | Drew Beatty Open Weight Overall Grand Champion |
| 2018 | Avery Plowden ( HW) Bailey Murphy LW Grand Champion | Morgan Plowden Overall Grand Champion |
| 2017 | Chris Gorham LW Grand Champion Avery Plowden HW Grand Champion | |
| 2016 | Willie Hicks (LW) Overall Grand Champion Jason Grenier (HW) Overall Grand Champion | Morgan Plowden Overall Grand Champion |
| 2015 | Jeremy Francoeur LW Grand Champion Ross Levine HW, Overall Grand Champion | |
| 2014 | Justin Ortiz LW Grand Champion Ross Levine HW Grand Champion Ross Levine Overall Grand Champion | Morgan Plowden |
| 2013 | Avery Plowden MW Grand Champion Jadi Tention HW 30-39 Grand Champion Jadi Tention Overall Grand Champion | Marissa Mayer Overall Grand Champion |
| 2012 | Ross Levine HW Grand Champion Jadi Tention HW 30-39 Grand Champion Jadi Tention Overall Grand Champion | Morgan Plowden |
| 2011 | Hamed Firouzi LW Grand Champion Ross Levine HW Grand Champion Hamed Firouzi Overall Grand Champion | Nicolle Pelland Overall Grand Champion |
| 2010 | Alex Lane MW Grand Champion Greg Betlach HW Grand Champion Greg Betlach Overall Grand Champion | Chelsey Nash Overall Grand Champion |
| 2009 | Ross Levine Superfights Grand Champion | Marielle Elliott Overall Grand Champion |
| 2008 | ||
| 2007 | ||
| 2006 | ||
| 2005 | Joyce Blanco Overall Grand Champion | |
| 2004 | Alex Lane LW Grand Champion Damon Gilbert HW Grand Champion Alex Lane Overall Grand Champion | Shelly Walwrath Overall Grad Champion |
| 2003 | ||
| 2002 | ||
| 2001 | Jason Bourelly LW Grand Champion Damon Gilbert HW Grand Champion Jason Bourelly Overall Grand Champion | Claire Cocozza Overall Grand Champion |
| 2000 | Raymond Daniels LW Grand Champion Ninja Fitzpatrick MW Grand Champion Raymond Daniels GC | Deshawn Bey Overall Grand Champion |
| 1999 | Raymond Daniels LW Grand Champion Jadi Tention HW Grand Champion | Dottie White MW Grand Champion |
| 1998 | ||
| 1997 | Nicki Carlson Lee Overall Grand Champion | |
| 1996 | Pedro Xavier LW Grand Champion Jerry Fontanez HW Grand Champion Reggie Perry MW Grand Champion | Nicki Carlson Lee Overall Grand Champion |
| 1995 | Jennifer Yanoff Overall Grand Champion | |
| 1994 | Tony Young LW Overall Grand Champion | Nicki Carlson Lee Overall Grand Champion |
| 1986 | Steve Nasty Anderson Overall Grand Champion | Linda Denley Overall Grand Champion |